Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and


10 thoughts on “Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and Transform the Middle East

  1. Sarah Sarah says:

    I have been interested in reading Embracing Israel Palestine for quite a while, but was also intimidated by its hefty length Unfortunately, overall I found the intimidation to be justified the book was not easy to read and it really felt like a project to get through it While he has some interesting ideas that I will be thinking about some , they are not presented with the clarity and crispness I was hoping for My primary criticism is that Lerner is extremely long winded and repetitive I have been interested in reading Embracing Israel Palestine for quite a while, but was also intimidated by its hefty length Unfortunately, overall I found the intimidation to be justified the book was not easy to read and it really felt like a project to get through it While he has some interesting ideas that I will be thinking about some , they are not presented with the clarity and crispness I was hoping for My primary criticism is that Lerner is extremely long winded and repetitive I think the book could have been muchsuccinct and shorter with better editing.The first two thirds present the complete history of the Palestinian region, through the lens of fairness and not assigning blame to either side or perhaps assigning it to both I found myself bored with and skimming through this section For one thing, I am already fairly familiar with the history from other books For another, I didn t need to be convinced that 1 both sides have done reprehensible things and 2 seen through different perspectives it is possible to understand why each side acted as they did I already agreed with Lerner s fundamental point in this section Finally, there was the fact that Lerner repeats his main points over and over again and goes into great detail about individual battles and skirmishes through the years and then this side attacked, and then this side retaliated, etc., etc , which got quite tiresome Perhaps for someone unfamiliar with the history or who strongly believes one side is right and the other wrong, this section of the book would beinteresting.In the last third of the book, Lerner presents his analysis of how peace in the region could be achieved This was what I was interested in and I readclosely here But again, overall I was a bit disappointed with his repetitiveness and lack of clarity in places He does present an interesting perspective namely, that both cultures are suffering from a societal level PTSD from past traumas and that peace will not be achieved until that is healed And how do we heal it The first step, according to Lerner, is to give people a chance to tell their stories out loud to others who listen without judgment and sympathetically urge them to fully allow themselves to grieve over their inner pain Now, this conclusion is essentially the same one I have reached through various readings and mediation training, and, while the PTSD framework is interesting, I don t think it is the only possible perspective that leads to the same conclusion about what needs to happen In general, I don t believe people are capable of seeing the other as having shared humanity until they have had an opportunity to tell their story and feel heard So, while it was interesting to read a new perspective, I didn t feel that there was anything really new to me here.From this analysis, Lerner proceeds to his perspective on how change actually comes about His ideas are essentially one of community organizing and grass roots change he clearly believes strongly in the power of the organic spreading of ideas to gradually bring about change Some of his arguments are compelling using examples from the past where this has happened but his overall perspective felt idealistic to me However, he does address this criticism head on, which I appreciated He presents the idea of two major worldviews, one of fear and domination and one of love and generosity Everyone has some of both in them and will fall on a continuum between the two Further, entire societies may swing between them at different periods in history How cynical one feels about his idealistic ideas is driven by where you and society are on the continuum at a given point in time This perspective resonates with me because I sometimes feelidealistic than others, and I can see how easy it is to get caught up in the fear and domination worldview in our current culture Lerner goes on to connect this perspective to religion, which does not hold much meaning for me For others, this part may becompelling, but for me it actually took away from it a bit I prefer to think of it in secular terms.In conclusion, Lerner has some interesting ideas and people who are less familiar with these sorts of arguments may getout of the book than I did However, his presentation is unfortunately long winded and it becomes a challenge to pull the gems out of it


  2. Sam Sam says:

    Marvelous book such a clear thinking, wise and compassionate person Uncomfortable to read at times as he challenges conscious and unconscious biases, but well worth it Whatecer your views and politics, you could only benefit from reading this book I am trying to apply his advice on how to deal with right wing bigots not that I meet many definitely work in progress.


  3. Nicholas Nicholas says:

    After reading a couple books by Leon Uris, I was inspired to seek out aeven handed account of the Israel Palestine situation This is exactly the book I was looking for One couldn t ask for aeven handed approach to the history, currents events, and the future There are a few points I particularly like about this book 1 Lerner freely admits his background and his biases He s a Jewish Rabbi, the son of American zionists But he s a whole hearted advocate for peace and reconciliatio After reading a couple books by Leon Uris, I was inspired to seek out aeven handed account of the Israel Palestine situation This is exactly the book I was looking for One couldn t ask for aeven handed approach to the history, currents events, and the future There are a few points I particularly like about this book 1 Lerner freely admits his background and his biases He s a Jewish Rabbi, the son of American zionists But he s a whole hearted advocate for peace and reconciliation and is highly critical of many of Israel s historical and contemporary actions 2 Lerner frames the discussion in a new and helpful way Instead of presenting the history to assess blame, he describes how each side has been wronged and has legitimate needs and grievances His principal point is that only by acknowledging these wrongs and grievances on both sides can we move on to a lasting peace.3 Lerner presents an intriguing theory that essentially says that he entire Jewish people have PTSD from 2000 years of anti semitism culminating in the holocaust Because of this, and because of the overwhelming feeling of betrayal from the rest of the world, which allowed the holocaust and mostly refused help, many Jews feel that they must never give in or be weak again Hence the destructive policies of the right wing in charge in israel 4 Lerner presents a nuanced view of things that require nuance, and strong opinions about things that require strong opinions He doesn t pull punches in criticizing the right or the left.As an example of his nuance, consider his response to the assertion that the Palestinians lost legitimacy when they rejected the original deal in 1947, Many Palestinians question whether the United Nations had the right to make the decision to split up the land into Israel and Palestine in 1947 Israelis who argue that the 1947 partition plan was legitimate are usually inconsistent when it comes to their own obligation to live by subsequent resolutions of the United Nations In fact, the rejection of the 1947 UN partition was a serious ethical and political mistake for which the entire Palestinian people have been paying for a long time Many Palestinians were born in those refugee camps or were under the age of 15 when the 1947 partition plan was rejected They have no moral culpability for the actions of those who took that decision in 1947, however disastrous it proved to be That s not to say this is a perfect book Lerner is unapologetically liberal, religiously and politically, and some of hisutopian views will turn off anyone right of center Which is a shame, because the fundamental points are independent of leftist politics I understand that Lerner feels that it s all connected, but somerestraint in some of his opinions such as doing away with a nation states altogether, for example would have made the bookaccessible to a wider audience That said, it s a very thoughtful and thought provoking work that I highly recommend


  4. Jon Jon says:

    Only 2 chapters in, but already I m humbled by the complexities of the Palestinian Israeli conflict Lerner skillfully walks a narrow path of presenting both sides of this reality Dipping into plenty of historical reference along the way, he refrains from getting mired in minutiae, while managing to paint what feels like a fair and complete picture of this bitter, long running conflict My western cultural upbringing, or perhaps it s simply my humanity, wants a side to be chosen already Lerner Only 2 chapters in, but already I m humbled by the complexities of the Palestinian Israeli conflict Lerner skillfully walks a narrow path of presenting both sides of this reality Dipping into plenty of historical reference along the way, he refrains from getting mired in minutiae, while managing to paint what feels like a fair and complete picture of this bitter, long running conflict My western cultural upbringing, or perhaps it s simply my humanity, wants a side to be chosen already Lerner shows me though that reality, in this case, isn t quite so simple One truth continues to emerge about both sides of this conflict, the fact that consistently, each fails to fully grasp the historical and cultural realities of The Other And as I see Lerner bring this truth to the surface again and again in this book, I see this as a pattern we humans follow during most times of conflict


  5. Mills College Library Mills College Library says:

    956.054 L6167 2011


  6. ماهر Battuti ماهر Battuti says:

    A well documented book, going back to history and personal experiences with Israelis and Palestinians It is presenting both contentions and gives answers and solutions


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and Transform the Middle East [Download] ➹ Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and Transform the Middle East Author Michael Lerner – Natus-physiotherapy.co.uk A major modern conundrum is how the Arab Israel conflict remains unresolved and, seemingly, unresolvable In this inspirational book, Rabbi Michael Lerner suggests that a change in consciousness is cru A major modern conundrum is how A Strategy PDF/EPUB ç the Arab Israel conflict remains unresolved and, seemingly, unresolvable In this inspirational Embracing Israel/Palestine: PDF/EPUB or book, Rabbi Michael Lerner suggests that a change in consciousness is crucial With clarity and honesty, he examines how Israel/Palestine: A Strategy PDF ✓ the mutual demonization and discounting of each sides legitimate needs drive the debate, and he points to new ways of thinking that can lead to a solution Lerner emphasizes that this new approach to the issue requires giving primacy to love, kindness, and generosity It calls for challenging the master narratives in both Israel and Palestine as well as the false idea that homeland security can be achieved through military, political, economic, or media domination Lerner makes the case that a lasting peace must prioritize helping people on all sides including Europe and the US and that real security is best achieved through an ethos of caring and generosity toward the other As many spiritual leaders have taught, problems like these cannot be solved at the same level at which they originated one must seek higher ground, and that becomes a central task for anyone who wants a sustainable peace Embracing Israel Palestine is written for those looking for positive, practical solutions to this ongoing dilemma.

    Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and of thinking that can lead to a solution Lerner emphasizes that this new approach to the issue requires giving primacy to love, kindness, and generosity It calls for challenging the master narratives in both Israel and Palestine as well as the false idea that homeland security can be achieved through military, political, economic, or media domination Lerner makes the case that a lasting peace must prioritize helping people on all sides including Europe and the US and that real security is best achieved through an ethos of caring and generosity toward the other As many spiritual leaders have taught, problems like these cannot be solved at the same level at which they originated one must seek higher ground, and that becomes a central task for anyone who wants a sustainable peace Embracing Israel Palestine is written for those looking for positive, practical solutions to this ongoing dilemma."/>
  • Paperback
  • 448 pages
  • Embracing Israel/Palestine: A Strategy to Heal and Transform the Middle East
  • Michael Lerner
  • English
  • 08 February 2017
  • 1583943072

About the Author: Michael Lerner

Is a well known author, some A Strategy PDF/EPUB ç of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Embracing Embracing Israel/Palestine: PDF/EPUB or IsraelPalestine: A Strategy to Heal and Transform the Middle East book, this is one of the most wanted Michael Israel/Palestine: A Strategy PDF ✓ Lerner author readers around the world.